Advertising 303: Generating More Revenue

Posted December 3rd, 2008 by KEZ

Advertising 101 took you through how and why to set up your site to display ads from any ad provider

Advertising 202 took you through which ad providers to use and why.

Advertising 303 is going to take you through how to make money. Whoo! However, I’ve already touched on a lot of this in my previous articles, so I’m going to start out by repeating myself.

The first way to increase revenue generated from displaying ads is to give the ads priority in your site design, whether those ads are served from ADSDAQ or Project Wonderful. I realize this goes against everything a webcomic site is supposed to be about (ie, you and your comic), and I don’t care, because I want to make money too.  By “priority” I mean placing ads before your site’s content, in this case, your comic. So, a leaderboard ABOVE your comic, a tower to the LEFT of your comic, and other ad sizes where available (example, a 300×250 box directly beneath your comic, not beneath your news area).  Ad providers generally offer two types of ads: above the fold, and below the fold. You get paid MORE for displaying above the fold ads, obviously.

Please keep in mind that even if these ads are given priority over your comic, people keep coming back FOR your comic, and no, ads will not make people stop coming back unless you completely overboard.  Mike, a commenter here, mentioned something called “ad blindness” a bit back, where internet viewers no longer even see ads.  It holds true. They see your content, and ignore the ads for the most part, which is EXACTLY the reason to get paid more, you need to put the ads before the content, so they [the ads] perform better.

What you DON’T want to do is place ads where people much scroll, either horizontally or vertically, to see them, unless they are specifically “below the fold” ads.  Sometimes this means you have to change your layout (DESIGN FOR THE ADS) or change your content (ex, no more wide-screen content).  What you also don’t want to do is allow “takeover” ads on your site, pop-ups, pop-unders, or ads that are expandable without hovering. These ads are a deterrent, and if you’ve got an archive of 50 or more pages, with these ads displayed on every page, NO ONE is going to read your comic.  Moderation is key, as well as taking care of your audience.  These types of ads can be turned off in your admin areas on Burst Media and ADSDAQ, and are obviously not allowed through Project Wonderful.

The second way to make more money is specifically for context-based advertisers like ADSDAQ.  These companies read the text on your page and then serve you ads that have something to do with that text. If you have little text on your page, you don’t get many ads (if you have no text, your application will not even be accepted).  These companies are NOT INTERESTED in serving ads that have nothing to do with your audience’s interests, and why should they be? It’s lose-lose for them and the people advertising if performance is horrible! Which is why having readable text on your page is extremely important.

But the question then becomes “well, what text should I have on my pages?”

  • Text about specific current events, politics, technologies, culture, or media RELEVANT to your audience.
  • Text about specific places you visited, how you got there, what you bought, where you went, with what transportation service, etc.
  • Text about specific companies, items, things you want to buy, gifts, holidays.

The key is being specific enough to get ads.  For example, let’s say I’m blogging about myself beneath my comic:

Hey guys! Yesterday I drove an hour to visit my friend and hang out with her. We checked out a bunch of things at the mall, but I didn’t buy anything.  We thought about seeing a movie, but decided instead to go out to eat. All in all, it was a fun day.

That is so vague that the only keywords I can find are “mall” and “movie.” This is not going to increase my fill rates much. Now, what if I transformed that into this?

Hey comic readers! Yesterday I drove to Rochester to visit my friend and have some fun at the local shopping mall called “the Medley Center.” We shopped for half the day, checking out stores like The Gap, Bon Ton and Dick’s Sporting Goods. I didn’t buy anything, but I found this fabulous athletic outfit that is just so cute! It’s Nike too (which was probably why it was so expensive! D:) We thought about seeing a movie at the theatre, perhaps the new James Bond flick Quantum of Solace, or maybe a comedy like Four Christmases, but decided to go eat at Outback Steakhouse instead. It was a great day, but wow, post-Thanksgiving at the mall is tough! I can’t even imagine what Christmas shopping will be like! It was still a lot of fun though!

This time, I highlighted the keywords for you (I went a little overboard, but I wanted to you get the general idea).  Mentioning CURRENT events/holidays gets you in on current ad campaigns that will shoot up your fill rates. This is why it is so important to write or update your text OFTEN. If you don’t, you get in on the new campaigns.  I mention specific places to get in on the “Travel” ads.  I mention specific stores to get ads related to merchandise sold there. Specific movies because when movies first come out, there are a LOT of ads going around. Etc, etc.

If you’re still confused, here is a screenshot of possible ad categories displayed on my site.  My next goal is to work on increasing specific ones.

possible adsdaq ad categories

The third way to increase ad revenue is to join multiple ad networks and set up an ad chain (as discussed in Advertising 202). You can see in the above image of ad categories that I have a lot of default views because my fill rates are not 100%. My fill rate at ADSDAQ is on average 15%, which leaves 85% to send elsewhere.  I send it to Burst Media, where my fill rate is also 15%. I send the rest of the views to defaults of my choice, in this case, free advertising for comics I enjoy.  If I joined more networks, I would get paid for more pageviews, which is my goal!  I next would like to join Tribal Fusion, but my audience is not yet large enough.  Tribal wants 2k uniques a day. I’m about half-way there. :D

The fourth and final way (that I use) to increase ad revenue is something again mentioned in a comment. I advertise through Project Wonderful to increase my total pageviews, and I make more money from the higher CPM of ads my site displays than I lose paying for the advertising itself. Make sense? PW prices are so awesomely low that just about every webcomicker out there can afford it, with average CPM being under 20 cents (in my personal experience.) In contrast, normal market CPM is 2-4 dollars, or higher.  Most of us don’t even think about our ads on PW being in CPM, we think in CPC and click-thru rates.  A good ad with PW will have a CPC (cost per click) of 0-3 cents.   If it costs more than that, as a webcomicker, you’re being ripped off!

I’m going to quote that aforementioned commenter, JGray, here, as he beat me to it:

“…people should consider at least one Project Wonderful ad on their site. If everyone uses PW and no one publishes PW there won’t be a PW to use. Plus, a good way to pay for PW is to use the funds they give you for publishing.”

This means more ads on your site, but it’s nice because it funds your OWN advertising through PW if you have a PW slot on your site.

This is the end of Advertising 303!  Next up: Advertising 404: The in-depth tutorial on setting up ad chains and default campaigns. When I can get to it, as it will require quite a view screen shots and coding quotes.

9 Responses to “Advertising 303: Generating More Revenue”

  1. Mike

    Sorry, but I couldn’t help notice the reference to me. XD I also couldn’t help notice that you missed the main point I was trying to make, which is no doubt my fault.

    The real danger of ad blindness these days—particularly on a site that’s overloaded with ads—is that people will begin ignoring content, not just ads.

    Your sidebar is a perfect example; I noticed (peripherally) the three tower ads in your sidebar and came to the immediate and incorrect conclusion that the entire thing was ads. It didn’t occur to me until much later that you actually split up your sidebar content with ads, and that hidden between the ads were useful links. And the only reason I realized that is because your banner doesn’t link to your site index for some reason and I had to spend a few seconds searching for a “Home” link.

    For an in depth look at web design and advertising with websites, I’ll recommend the Smashing Magazine article: Advertising and It’s Impact on Web Design.

  2. KEZ

    Hehe, I still think you MADE my point, Mike. Ad blindness isn’t about what’s between the ads ONLY, it’s about the eyes seeing the ad and the brain telling you to ignore it due to an oversaturation of ads on sites. The point you were trying to make was that you ignored the content between them, and the point I made from you making that point was that ad blindness exists, it means people ignore the ads, and it means to make more money, you have to force more attention to the ads especially when the ads are performance based.

    I guess you made my point in periphery. If you would like me to change that section about in the article, I would be happy to.

  3. Liliy

    I think his point was that if people get frustrated enough with advertising overrunning the content, they’ll stop visiting the site which means that neither the content nor the ads will be viewed.

    Unless your site is completely funded by advertising, like say a magazine or a newspaper, it usually isn’t wise to put ad priority above content.

    His case about your sidebar falls under a different category though. Shoving ads in between your link content doesn’t work very well aesthetically or functionally. A large cluster of ads turns the reader away, and important navigation information is lost in the confusion. It wouldn’t be as horrible if it were a small ad in between the sections, but you have a large ad, a few links, and then a second cluster. Just scanning your sidebar I assumed your Tag Cloud was a text ad.

    However, if you wanted to put ad revenue as the site priority (which is an option), than I’d put the banner ad ABOVE your page and category links so it falls ‘above the fold’ And follow that by making your header clickable so people don’t have to search the page for the home. That way the ads aren’t splitting your content and the ad gets priority. :D

  4. JGray

    The timing is very coincidental, but since starting up your articles on advertising, ADSDAQ has begun dropping webcomics, including some relatively well read ones. People might want to beware there.

  5. KEZ

    @JGray: I’ve heard about ADSDAQ screwing over comic folks lately. It’s pissing everybody off, and no one really knows why they’re doing this. Some sites that have been declined have plenty of text. We’re all crossing our fingers hoping we’re not next! I’m hoping all of text content I have will save my site with them. If not, I’ve signed up recently with a bunch of other ad providers also.

    @Liliy: Thanks for your comments! What I have between my ads is content I don’t consider “important” to anything much except the serious blog browser, and for context-based advertisers. Even if readers don’t see what’s between the ads, the web crawlers will, which is all I need. Otherwise, the “pages” menu above the ads has the only real priority. If I put all or any ads above the content, people have to scroll for the navigation, which is a no-no. I thank you for your opinions on the matter^^

  6. JGray

    I know of Clan of the Cats, Multiplex, and Questionable Content. QC is text light but Multiplex and CotC aren’t, I don’t think.

    Could be that ADSDAQ has to tighten their belt and are whittling down their publishers in order to save money? I’m not sure how that would work but maybe they don’t have the resources to properly track the numbers they have now in order to make sure all is going as planned.

    Dunno. Could be they’re just going wikipedia on comic’s.

  7. JGray

    And g’luck. I hope you’re not dropped.

  8. JGray

    I thought this might be useful. Its a form letter, apparently, that ADSDAQ is sending out:

    ContextWeb conducts ongoing evaluations of accounts and domains within the ADSDAQ Exchange. Some ADSDAQ accounts have had domains declined as a result of this continuous auditing process. This is done to ensure that we continue to deliver the strongest content based inventory to ADSDAQ advertisers so they continue to allocate their spending onto the exchange and its publishers.

    If you have been a part of the ADSDAQ Exchange but received a decline notice, we thank you for your business. Any domain(s) that have been declined no longer meet requirements of the exchange (please see below for decline reasons). Domain(s) declined will not be reconsidered for placement in the exchange. All traffic will be routed to the backup tag in a publisher’s account, until publishers have a chance to remove the ADSDAQ Ad tags from their pages. Thanks again for your understanding about this important issue.

    Domains are declined in the Exchange for the following reasons:
    Domain is in a language other than English
    Domain is primarily a social networking application
    Domain has a high volume of graphics and images such as anime or comic strips
    Domain facilitates file or MP3 sharing or is a hosting site for user uploaded video, photo or music
    Domain has poor quality or minimal content.
    Domain is “under construction” broken and has little or no content
    Domain is a “MFA” or “Made for Ads” site whose primary purpose is to generate clicks
    Domain contains stolen content/copy write issue – not original content
    Domain contains adult language, adult images or content, hate speech or discussion of illegal drugs, alcohol or gambling.
    Domains that are game or gaming
    Domains with comic strips

  9. JGray

    Likely you’re sick of hearing this but I thought I’d pass on the news as I’m hearing it.

    Apparently, Sheldon, Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal, Shortpacked, and Bellen have all been dropped.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Comments links could be nofollow free.